So this idea has bubbled back to the surface again,( good time to sneak the news through while the MPs are away) and the UK Government are " inviting tenders " for a National ID card scheme to " deal with terrorism"
Words almost, but not quite, fail me.
Lets look at this proposal bit by bit.
First
Cost, It is suggested that the scheme will cost £6 billion, yeh just like the Dome was going to cost £50 million and cost £1 billion,
the little boys club and debating chamber otherwise known as the Scottish Parliament Building, originally going to cost £10 million, actual cost £450 million
or perhaps the IT system that is most similar in scope to the ID card scheme - the NHS IT system - this too was originally going to cost £6 billion.
The scheme is now years and years late, doesn't do any of the things that were promised, very well if at all and the final cost is unknown but " probably in excess of £31 billion"
If you know where to look you will find legions of failed IT schemes embarked upon by Government that failed totally and were quietly taken behind the barn and shot, away from public view. The casual way in which expenditure like £40 million on, say Trawlerman, was just abandoned is quite breathtaking and thats just one out of hundreds of similar failed projects.
Looking back I can only think of one Government IT project finished on budget and on time, coincidentally its also the only occassion I can think of where the civil servant responsible got fired, obviously Jane let the side down by doing the job properly.
Back to ID cards - in summary the costs will be astronomic and not controlled.
Lets look at the technology, simple really, the technology to do what is wanted does not exist any where in the World - period
So lets look at the setting up of the system
there are somewhere around 60,000,000 Brits, so just entering the data, in a 100% reliable and accurate manner will not only involve something north of 20,000 man years of work, the chances of it being correct are absolutely zero. A good example of the hurdles to be jumped is that there are at least 15 ways of spelling Mohammed, I choose that as an example as it is now in the Top 10 given names in the UK.
Finally " it will help defeat terrorism" give me a break please,what just like the USA system did with the 9/11 bombers.(it is ironic that a nation like the USA that spends trillions on defence and security was humiliated for the cost of a few air tickets)
Any, and I mean any, piece of IT gadgetry that the UK introduces will be made up of components from all around the World, that will be very easy for those so minded to obtain. My estimate is that it will take about one month for the first forged ID cards to appear, thus negating the whole system.
ID cards, we cannot afford them, we don't need them and they won't work, so why are we even talking about them.
Oh I forgot we have a control freak as PM and the faceless ones that control the EU have instructed that we have to.